diff --git a/browser/resources/settings/default_brave_shields_page/default_brave_shields_page.ts b/browser/resources/settings/default_brave_shields_page/default_brave_shields_page.ts
index 10505a0f120..671ac236bcc 100644
--- a/browser/resources/settings/default_brave_shields_page/default_brave_shields_page.ts
+++ b/browser/resources/settings/default_brave_shields_page/default_brave_shields_page.ts
@@ -179,6 +179,11 @@ class BraveShieldsPage extends BraveShieldsPageBase {
 
     this.browserProxy_.getFingerprintingControlType().then(value => {
       this.fingerprintingControlType_ = value
+      this.isFingerprintingEnabled_ = {
+        key: '',
+        type: chrome.settingsPrivate.PrefType.BOOLEAN,
+        value: value != 'allow',
+      }
     })
 
     this.browserProxy_.getHttpsUpgradeControlType().then(value => {